{"name":"CivStat — Civilization Score","methodVersion":"3.0","previousMethod":{"version":"2","year":2025,"civScore":67.1},"estimateNote":"Points with estimate=true (before 1900) are CivStat estimates, not computed from published indicators.","dataUpdated":"2026-11-01T08:33:42.717Z","license":"CC BY 4.0","citation":"CivStat (2026). Civilization Score, method v3.0. https://civstat.com","method":"https://civstat.com/methodology","lenses":{"balanced":{"thinker":"Equal weights","weights":{"conflictIndex":1,"welfareIndex":1,"knowledgeIndex":1,"freedomIndex":1,"sustainabilityIndex":1,"cooperationIndex":1},"weakestLinkShare":0},"pinker":{"thinker":"Steven Pinker · Enlightenment Now","weights":{"conflictIndex":2,"welfareIndex":2.5,"knowledgeIndex":2,"freedomIndex":1,"sustainabilityIndex":0.5,"cooperationIndex":1},"weakestLinkShare":0},"sen":{"thinker":"Amartya Sen · Development as Freedom","weights":{"conflictIndex":1,"welfareIndex":2,"knowledgeIndex":1.5,"freedomIndex":2.5,"sustainabilityIndex":0.5,"cooperationIndex":1},"weakestLinkShare":0},"rockstrom":{"thinker":"Johan Rockström · Planetary Boundaries","weights":{"conflictIndex":1,"welfareIndex":1,"knowledgeIndex":0.5,"freedomIndex":0.5,"sustainabilityIndex":3.5,"cooperationIndex":1.5},"weakestLinkShare":0},"taleb":{"thinker":"Nassim Taleb · Antifragile","weights":{"conflictIndex":2.5,"welfareIndex":1,"knowledgeIndex":0.5,"freedomIndex":1,"sustainabilityIndex":2.5,"cooperationIndex":1.5},"weakestLinkShare":0.5}},"latest":{"year":2026,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0.98,"provisional":true,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.6,"welfare":77.4,"knowledge":65.7,"freedom":45.6,"sustainability":39.5,"cooperation":77.2},"fragility":41.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":65.1,"sen":61.6,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":48.6}},"series":[{"year":1900,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.7,"welfare":28.7,"knowledge":10.2,"freedom":14.1,"sustainability":83.7,"cooperation":24.7},"fragility":42.4,"civscore":{"balanced":37.6,"pinker":33.5,"sen":28.1,"rockstrom":54.4,"taleb":30.4}},{"year":1901,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.7,"welfare":28.8,"knowledge":10.4,"freedom":14.2,"sustainability":83.7,"cooperation":25},"fragility":42,"civscore":{"balanced":37.9,"pinker":33.8,"sen":28.3,"rockstrom":54.6,"taleb":30.7}},{"year":1902,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.2,"welfare":29,"knowledge":10.6,"freedom":14.3,"sustainability":84,"cooperation":25.3},"fragility":41.6,"civscore":{"balanced":38.2,"pinker":34.1,"sen":28.6,"rockstrom":54.9,"taleb":30.9}},{"year":1903,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.8,"welfare":29.1,"knowledge":10.8,"freedom":14.4,"sustainability":84.2,"cooperation":25.6},"fragility":38.7,"civscore":{"balanced":39.7,"pinker":36.1,"sen":29.7,"rockstrom":56.1,"taleb":32.3}},{"year":1904,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.5,"welfare":29.2,"knowledge":11,"freedom":14.4,"sustainability":84.2,"cooperation":26},"fragility":42.1,"civscore":{"balanced":38.1,"pinker":33.8,"sen":28.5,"rockstrom":54.9,"taleb":30.9}},{"year":1905,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.1,"welfare":29.4,"knowledge":11.2,"freedom":14.5,"sustainability":83.4,"cooperation":26.3},"fragility":42.1,"civscore":{"balanced":38.1,"pinker":34,"sen":28.7,"rockstrom":54.7,"taleb":31}},{"year":1906,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.7,"welfare":29.5,"knowledge":11.4,"freedom":14.7,"sustainability":82.9,"cooperation":26.6},"fragility":38.7,"civscore":{"balanced":39.9,"pinker":36.4,"sen":30,"rockstrom":55.9,"taleb":32.5}},{"year":1907,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.7,"welfare":29.7,"knowledge":11.6,"freedom":14.7,"sustainability":83.3,"cooperation":26.9},"fragility":38.5,"civscore":{"balanced":40.1,"pinker":36.6,"sen":30.2,"rockstrom":56.1,"taleb":32.7}},{"year":1908,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.51,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.7,"welfare":29.8,"knowledge":11.8,"freedom":14.8,"sustainability":83.2,"cooperation":27.2},"fragility":38.4,"civscore":{"balanced":40.2,"pinker":36.7,"sen":30.3,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":32.8}},{"year":1909,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.7,"welfare":30,"knowledge":12,"freedom":14.9,"sustainability":83.1,"cooperation":27.5},"fragility":38.4,"civscore":{"balanced":40.3,"pinker":36.8,"sen":30.4,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":33}},{"year":1910,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.6,"welfare":30.1,"knowledge":12.2,"freedom":15,"sustainability":82.9,"cooperation":27.8},"fragility":38.3,"civscore":{"balanced":40.4,"pinker":37,"sen":30.5,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":33.1}},{"year":1911,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":26.8,"welfare":30.2,"knowledge":12.5,"freedom":15.1,"sustainability":82.8,"cooperation":28.2},"fragility":38.6,"civscore":{"balanced":40.3,"pinker":36.8,"sen":30.6,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":33.1}},{"year":1912,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.1,"welfare":30.4,"knowledge":12.7,"freedom":15.5,"sustainability":82.4,"cooperation":28.5},"fragility":41.7,"civscore":{"balanced":38.9,"pinker":34.9,"sen":29.7,"rockstrom":54.9,"taleb":31.9}},{"year":1913,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.4,"welfare":30.5,"knowledge":12.9,"freedom":15.6,"sustainability":82.2,"cooperation":28.8},"fragility":41.8,"civscore":{"balanced":38.9,"pinker":35,"sen":29.7,"rockstrom":54.9,"taleb":32}},{"year":1914,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":53.5,"welfare":30.7,"knowledge":13.1,"freedom":15.4,"sustainability":81.4,"cooperation":29.1},"fragility":47.7,"civscore":{"balanced":36,"pinker":31.2,"sen":27.7,"rockstrom":52.5,"taleb":29.7}},{"year":1915,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":54.6,"welfare":30.8,"knowledge":13.3,"freedom":15.5,"sustainability":81,"cooperation":28.8},"fragility":48.3,"civscore":{"balanced":35.8,"pinker":31,"sen":27.6,"rockstrom":52.2,"taleb":29.5}},{"year":1916,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":54.5,"welfare":30.9,"knowledge":13.6,"freedom":15.6,"sustainability":81.5,"cooperation":28.5},"fragility":48.2,"civscore":{"balanced":35.9,"pinker":31.1,"sen":27.8,"rockstrom":52.4,"taleb":29.8}},{"year":1917,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":54.5,"welfare":31.1,"knowledge":13.8,"freedom":15.6,"sustainability":81.7,"cooperation":28.2},"fragility":48.2,"civscore":{"balanced":36,"pinker":31.2,"sen":27.8,"rockstrom":52.4,"taleb":29.9}},{"year":1918,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":53,"welfare":31.2,"knowledge":14,"freedom":15.8,"sustainability":81.2,"cooperation":27.9},"fragility":48,"civscore":{"balanced":36.2,"pinker":31.6,"sen":28,"rockstrom":52.4,"taleb":30.1}},{"year":1919,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.5,"welfare":31.3,"knowledge":14.3,"freedom":16.5,"sustainability":80.7,"cooperation":27.6},"fragility":45.1,"civscore":{"balanced":37.8,"pinker":33.8,"sen":29.4,"rockstrom":53.4,"taleb":31.6}},{"year":1920,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.4,"welfare":31.5,"knowledge":14.5,"freedom":16.9,"sustainability":80.4,"cooperation":27.3},"fragility":44.9,"civscore":{"balanced":38,"pinker":34.2,"sen":29.7,"rockstrom":53.4,"taleb":31.8}},{"year":1921,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.4,"welfare":31.8,"knowledge":14.8,"freedom":17,"sustainability":80,"cooperation":27},"fragility":42.8,"civscore":{"balanced":39.2,"pinker":35.8,"sen":30.6,"rockstrom":54.1,"taleb":32.9}},{"year":1922,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.4,"welfare":32.2,"knowledge":15,"freedom":17.1,"sustainability":80.1,"cooperation":26.6},"fragility":42.9,"civscore":{"balanced":39.3,"pinker":35.9,"sen":30.7,"rockstrom":54.1,"taleb":33}},{"year":1923,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":27.4,"welfare":32.5,"knowledge":15.2,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":79.9,"cooperation":26.3},"fragility":40.4,"civscore":{"balanced":40.6,"pinker":37.8,"sen":31.7,"rockstrom":55.1,"taleb":34.2}},{"year":1924,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":29.2,"welfare":32.9,"knowledge":15.5,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":79.7,"cooperation":25.9},"fragility":41.2,"civscore":{"balanced":40.3,"pinker":37.5,"sen":31.6,"rockstrom":54.7,"taleb":34}},{"year":1925,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.8,"welfare":33.2,"knowledge":15.7,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":79.5,"cooperation":25.6},"fragility":43.2,"civscore":{"balanced":39.4,"pinker":36.4,"sen":31,"rockstrom":53.9,"taleb":33.3}},{"year":1926,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.4,"welfare":33.6,"knowledge":15.9,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":78.8,"cooperation":25.2},"fragility":43.5,"civscore":{"balanced":39.4,"pinker":36.5,"sen":31.1,"rockstrom":53.7,"taleb":33.4}},{"year":1927,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":32.8,"welfare":33.9,"knowledge":16.2,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":78.9,"cooperation":24.8},"fragility":43,"civscore":{"balanced":39.7,"pinker":37,"sen":31.4,"rockstrom":53.9,"taleb":33.7}},{"year":1928,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":32.7,"welfare":34.2,"knowledge":16.4,"freedom":17.2,"sustainability":78.7,"cooperation":24.5},"fragility":43.2,"civscore":{"balanced":39.7,"pinker":37.1,"sen":31.4,"rockstrom":53.8,"taleb":33.8}},{"year":1929,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.2,"welfare":34.6,"knowledge":16.7,"freedom":17.3,"sustainability":79.1,"cooperation":24.1},"fragility":40.7,"civscore":{"balanced":41.1,"pinker":38.9,"sen":32.5,"rockstrom":54.9,"taleb":35.1}},{"year":1930,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.8,"welfare":34.9,"knowledge":16.9,"freedom":17.3,"sustainability":78.2,"cooperation":23.8},"fragility":44.9,"civscore":{"balanced":39.1,"pinker":36.4,"sen":31.1,"rockstrom":53.1,"taleb":33.4}},{"year":1931,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.1,"welfare":35.3,"knowledge":17.1,"freedom":17.4,"sustainability":77.8,"cooperation":23.9},"fragility":43.8,"civscore":{"balanced":39.7,"pinker":37.4,"sen":31.7,"rockstrom":53.5,"taleb":34}},{"year":1932,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.7,"welfare":35.6,"knowledge":17.4,"freedom":17.7,"sustainability":77.8,"cooperation":24},"fragility":44.3,"civscore":{"balanced":39.6,"pinker":37.2,"sen":31.7,"rockstrom":53.3,"taleb":34}},{"year":1933,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":28.1,"welfare":36,"knowledge":17.6,"freedom":17.4,"sustainability":78.1,"cooperation":24.1},"fragility":42,"civscore":{"balanced":40.9,"pinker":38.8,"sen":32.6,"rockstrom":54.4,"taleb":35}},{"year":1934,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":28.9,"welfare":36.3,"knowledge":17.9,"freedom":17.5,"sustainability":77.5,"cooperation":24.2},"fragility":42.4,"civscore":{"balanced":40.7,"pinker":38.8,"sen":32.6,"rockstrom":54.1,"taleb":34.9}},{"year":1935,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":29.5,"welfare":36.6,"knowledge":18.1,"freedom":18,"sustainability":77.4,"cooperation":24.3},"fragility":42.6,"civscore":{"balanced":40.8,"pinker":38.9,"sen":32.8,"rockstrom":54.1,"taleb":35.1}},{"year":1936,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.3,"welfare":37,"knowledge":18.5,"freedom":18.1,"sustainability":77.1,"cooperation":24.4},"fragility":44.9,"civscore":{"balanced":39.8,"pinker":37.6,"sen":32.2,"rockstrom":53.2,"taleb":34.2}},{"year":1937,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.3,"welfare":37.3,"knowledge":18.8,"freedom":18.2,"sustainability":76.4,"cooperation":24.5},"fragility":47.5,"civscore":{"balanced":38.7,"pinker":36.1,"sen":31.5,"rockstrom":52.1,"taleb":33.2}},{"year":1938,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.3,"welfare":37.7,"knowledge":19.2,"freedom":18.4,"sustainability":76.3,"cooperation":24.6},"fragility":47.5,"civscore":{"balanced":38.8,"pinker":36.4,"sen":31.7,"rockstrom":52.1,"taleb":33.4}},{"year":1939,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":46,"welfare":38,"knowledge":19.6,"freedom":18.3,"sustainability":76.2,"cooperation":24.7},"fragility":48.4,"civscore":{"balanced":38.5,"pinker":35.9,"sen":31.5,"rockstrom":51.8,"taleb":33}},{"year":1940,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":46.3,"welfare":38.3,"knowledge":19.9,"freedom":18.1,"sustainability":75.6,"cooperation":24.8},"fragility":48.6,"civscore":{"balanced":38.4,"pinker":36,"sen":31.5,"rockstrom":51.6,"taleb":32.8}},{"year":1941,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":57.8,"welfare":38.7,"knowledge":20.3,"freedom":18.2,"sustainability":75.6,"cooperation":24.9},"fragility":52.4,"civscore":{"balanced":36.7,"pinker":33.6,"sen":30.4,"rockstrom":50.3,"taleb":31.3}},{"year":1942,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":57.7,"welfare":39.1,"knowledge":20.6,"freedom":18.3,"sustainability":75.5,"cooperation":25},"fragility":52.4,"civscore":{"balanced":36.8,"pinker":33.8,"sen":30.6,"rockstrom":50.3,"taleb":31.4}},{"year":1943,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":57.7,"welfare":39.4,"knowledge":21,"freedom":18.4,"sustainability":75.3,"cooperation":25.1},"fragility":52.4,"civscore":{"balanced":36.9,"pinker":34,"sen":30.7,"rockstrom":50.3,"taleb":31.4}},{"year":1944,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":57.9,"welfare":39.8,"knowledge":21.3,"freedom":18.6,"sustainability":74.7,"cooperation":25.2},"fragility":52.7,"civscore":{"balanced":36.9,"pinker":34.2,"sen":30.9,"rockstrom":50.1,"taleb":31.5}},{"year":1945,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.47,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":57.7,"welfare":40.1,"knowledge":21.7,"freedom":19.2,"sustainability":74.8,"cooperation":25.3},"fragility":52.5,"civscore":{"balanced":37.2,"pinker":34.5,"sen":31.3,"rockstrom":50.3,"taleb":31.9}},{"year":1946,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":44.3,"welfare":40.5,"knowledge":22.1,"freedom":20.2,"sustainability":75.2,"cooperation":26.3},"fragility":47.6,"civscore":{"balanced":40,"pinker":37.9,"sen":33.4,"rockstrom":52.5,"taleb":34.5}},{"year":1947,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":45.9,"welfare":40.8,"knowledge":22.4,"freedom":20.8,"sustainability":74.9,"cooperation":27.2},"fragility":47.9,"civscore":{"balanced":40,"pinker":37.8,"sen":33.6,"rockstrom":52.4,"taleb":34.6}},{"year":1948,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":47.7,"welfare":41.2,"knowledge":22.8,"freedom":21.2,"sustainability":74.9,"cooperation":28.2},"fragility":48.2,"civscore":{"balanced":40.1,"pinker":37.8,"sen":33.8,"rockstrom":52.5,"taleb":34.7}},{"year":1949,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":47.6,"welfare":41.6,"knowledge":23.1,"freedom":21.7,"sustainability":74.8,"cooperation":29.2},"fragility":47.9,"civscore":{"balanced":40.5,"pinker":38.1,"sen":34.2,"rockstrom":52.8,"taleb":35.1}},{"year":1950,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":48.3,"welfare":41.9,"knowledge":23.5,"freedom":22.3,"sustainability":74.9,"cooperation":30.1},"fragility":47.8,"civscore":{"balanced":40.7,"pinker":38.3,"sen":34.6,"rockstrom":53,"taleb":35.5}},{"year":1951,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":46,"welfare":42.3,"knowledge":24.1,"freedom":22.6,"sustainability":74,"cooperation":30.8},"fragility":47.1,"civscore":{"balanced":41.3,"pinker":39.2,"sen":35.2,"rockstrom":53.1,"taleb":35.9}},{"year":1952,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.8,"welfare":42.7,"knowledge":24.7,"freedom":23.9,"sustainability":73.4,"cooperation":31.5},"fragility":45.3,"civscore":{"balanced":42.6,"pinker":40.7,"sen":36.4,"rockstrom":53.8,"taleb":37.4}},{"year":1953,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":38.9,"welfare":43.2,"knowledge":25.4,"freedom":24.4,"sustainability":72.8,"cooperation":32.2},"fragility":44.6,"civscore":{"balanced":43.2,"pinker":41.6,"sen":37.1,"rockstrom":54,"taleb":37.9}},{"year":1954,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.8,"welfare":43.6,"knowledge":26,"freedom":24.7,"sustainability":73,"cooperation":32.9},"fragility":43.6,"civscore":{"balanced":43.9,"pinker":42.4,"sen":37.7,"rockstrom":54.6,"taleb":38.5}},{"year":1955,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":32.2,"welfare":44,"knowledge":26.7,"freedom":24.9,"sustainability":72.9,"cooperation":33.6},"fragility":41.9,"civscore":{"balanced":45,"pinker":43.8,"sen":38.6,"rockstrom":55.4,"taleb":39.4}},{"year":1956,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.1,"welfare":44.4,"knowledge":27.3,"freedom":25.2,"sustainability":72.8,"cooperation":34.3},"fragility":42.3,"civscore":{"balanced":45,"pinker":43.7,"sen":38.7,"rockstrom":55.4,"taleb":39.3}},{"year":1957,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":32.8,"welfare":44.8,"knowledge":28,"freedom":25.5,"sustainability":71.7,"cooperation":35},"fragility":42,"civscore":{"balanced":45.4,"pinker":44.3,"sen":39.2,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":39.6}},{"year":1958,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.8,"welfare":45.2,"knowledge":28.7,"freedom":25.6,"sustainability":71.3,"cooperation":35.7},"fragility":42.6,"civscore":{"balanced":45.3,"pinker":44.2,"sen":39.3,"rockstrom":55.1,"taleb":39.5}},{"year":1959,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.8,"welfare":45.6,"knowledge":29.4,"freedom":25.6,"sustainability":71.1,"cooperation":36.4},"fragility":42.4,"civscore":{"balanced":45.6,"pinker":44.5,"sen":39.6,"rockstrom":55.2,"taleb":39.5}},{"year":1960,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.6,"welfare":46,"knowledge":30,"freedom":26,"sustainability":70.9,"cooperation":37.2},"fragility":42.5,"civscore":{"balanced":45.8,"pinker":44.7,"sen":39.9,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":39.7}},{"year":1961,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":37.3,"welfare":46.9,"knowledge":30.7,"freedom":26.2,"sustainability":70.3,"cooperation":37.9},"fragility":43,"civscore":{"balanced":45.8,"pinker":44.8,"sen":40.1,"rockstrom":55.1,"taleb":39.6}},{"year":1962,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.3,"welfare":48,"knowledge":31.3,"freedom":26.3,"sustainability":70.1,"cooperation":38.6},"fragility":42.2,"civscore":{"balanced":46.5,"pinker":45.8,"sen":40.8,"rockstrom":55.6,"taleb":40.1}},{"year":1963,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.2,"welfare":48.4,"knowledge":32,"freedom":26.6,"sustainability":69.7,"cooperation":39.3},"fragility":42.4,"civscore":{"balanced":46.6,"pinker":45.9,"sen":41.1,"rockstrom":55.6,"taleb":40.2}},{"year":1964,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.4,"welfare":48.9,"knowledge":32.6,"freedom":26.7,"sustainability":70.2,"cooperation":40},"fragility":42.1,"civscore":{"balanced":47,"pinker":46.3,"sen":41.4,"rockstrom":56,"taleb":40.4}},{"year":1965,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":38.9,"welfare":49.1,"knowledge":33.2,"freedom":26.7,"sustainability":69.5,"cooperation":40.7},"fragility":42.9,"civscore":{"balanced":46.7,"pinker":45.9,"sen":41.3,"rockstrom":55.6,"taleb":40}},{"year":1966,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":38.8,"welfare":49.6,"knowledge":33.9,"freedom":26.8,"sustainability":69,"cooperation":41.4},"fragility":42.8,"civscore":{"balanced":47,"pinker":46.3,"sen":41.7,"rockstrom":55.6,"taleb":40.1}},{"year":1967,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.9,"welfare":50,"knowledge":34.6,"freedom":27,"sustainability":68.6,"cooperation":42.1},"fragility":43.4,"civscore":{"balanced":46.9,"pinker":46.2,"sen":41.8,"rockstrom":55.4,"taleb":40}},{"year":1968,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.7,"welfare":50.5,"knowledge":35.4,"freedom":27.2,"sustainability":68.4,"cooperation":42.8},"fragility":43.8,"civscore":{"balanced":46.9,"pinker":46.2,"sen":41.9,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":39.9}},{"year":1969,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.45,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.2,"welfare":50.9,"knowledge":36.1,"freedom":27.3,"sustainability":67.6,"cooperation":43.5},"fragility":43.7,"civscore":{"balanced":47.2,"pinker":46.6,"sen":42.3,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":40}},{"year":1970,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.36,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":41.8,"welfare":51.3,"knowledge":36.8,"freedom":27.5,"sustainability":67.5,"cooperation":44.2},"fragility":43.4,"civscore":{"balanced":47.6,"pinker":47.1,"sen":42.7,"rockstrom":55.5,"taleb":40.3}},{"year":1971,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.36,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.4,"welfare":51.5,"knowledge":35.5,"freedom":27.5,"sustainability":67.4,"cooperation":44.5},"fragility":43.8,"civscore":{"balanced":47.2,"pinker":46.5,"sen":42.3,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":40.1}},{"year":1972,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.6,"welfare":52.1,"knowledge":36.4,"freedom":27.7,"sustainability":66.6,"cooperation":44.8},"fragility":44.1,"civscore":{"balanced":47.3,"pinker":46.9,"sen":42.7,"rockstrom":55.1,"taleb":40.1}},{"year":1973,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":41.7,"welfare":52.4,"knowledge":36.8,"freedom":28.1,"sustainability":65.7,"cooperation":47},"fragility":43,"civscore":{"balanced":48.1,"pinker":47.7,"sen":43.3,"rockstrom":55.5,"taleb":40.7}},{"year":1974,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.8,"welfare":52.8,"knowledge":37.6,"freedom":28.3,"sustainability":65.9,"cooperation":50.2},"fragility":42.2,"civscore":{"balanced":48.7,"pinker":48.1,"sen":43.9,"rockstrom":56.1,"taleb":41}},{"year":1975,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":39.6,"welfare":53.2,"knowledge":38.1,"freedom":27.9,"sustainability":65.3,"cooperation":49.3},"fragility":41.7,"civscore":{"balanced":49,"pinker":48.9,"sen":44.2,"rockstrom":56.1,"taleb":41.1}},{"year":1976,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":38.6,"welfare":53.7,"knowledge":38.4,"freedom":28,"sustainability":65.2,"cooperation":50.1},"fragility":41.1,"civscore":{"balanced":49.5,"pinker":49.4,"sen":44.6,"rockstrom":56.5,"taleb":41.4}},{"year":1977,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.7,"welfare":54.3,"knowledge":38.8,"freedom":28.9,"sustainability":63.7,"cooperation":50.6},"fragility":40.1,"civscore":{"balanced":50.3,"pinker":50.6,"sen":45.5,"rockstrom":56.5,"taleb":42.3}},{"year":1978,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":39.1,"welfare":54.8,"knowledge":39.3,"freedom":30.2,"sustainability":63.6,"cooperation":51.1},"fragility":41.5,"civscore":{"balanced":50,"pinker":50.1,"sen":45.6,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":42.5}},{"year":1979,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":41.7,"welfare":55.3,"knowledge":39.8,"freedom":30.8,"sustainability":62.9,"cooperation":52.8},"fragility":42,"civscore":{"balanced":50,"pinker":49.9,"sen":45.9,"rockstrom":56,"taleb":42.5}},{"year":1980,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.4,"welfare":55.8,"knowledge":40.2,"freedom":31.3,"sustainability":62,"cooperation":54.9},"fragility":41.2,"civscore":{"balanced":50.6,"pinker":50.7,"sen":46.5,"rockstrom":56.3,"taleb":43.1}},{"year":1981,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.7,"welfare":56,"knowledge":40.7,"freedom":31.6,"sustainability":61.4,"cooperation":55.4},"fragility":42,"civscore":{"balanced":50.4,"pinker":50.4,"sen":46.5,"rockstrom":55.9,"taleb":42.9}},{"year":1982,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.7,"welfare":56.2,"knowledge":41.1,"freedom":31.9,"sustainability":61.7,"cooperation":54.5},"fragility":42.5,"civscore":{"balanced":50.3,"pinker":50.3,"sen":46.5,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":42.9}},{"year":1983,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.2,"welfare":56.5,"knowledge":41.5,"freedom":32.3,"sustainability":60.6,"cooperation":54.3},"fragility":42.8,"civscore":{"balanced":50.3,"pinker":50.5,"sen":46.8,"rockstrom":55.5,"taleb":43.1}},{"year":1984,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.33,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43.3,"welfare":56.7,"knowledge":42.1,"freedom":32.7,"sustainability":60.7,"cooperation":55.3},"fragility":42.4,"civscore":{"balanced":50.7,"pinker":50.9,"sen":47.1,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":43.4}},{"year":1985,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.31,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.1,"welfare":56.9,"knowledge":42.5,"freedom":33.3,"sustainability":60.2,"cooperation":55.4},"fragility":42.2,"civscore":{"balanced":51,"pinker":51.3,"sen":47.6,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":43.9}},{"year":1986,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.31,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":43,"welfare":57.6,"knowledge":42.7,"freedom":33.8,"sustainability":59.6,"cooperation":54.1},"fragility":43.1,"civscore":{"balanced":50.8,"pinker":51.2,"sen":47.6,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":43.9}},{"year":1987,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.31,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.4,"welfare":58.2,"knowledge":43.1,"freedom":34.3,"sustainability":58.7,"cooperation":55.2},"fragility":42.8,"civscore":{"balanced":51.2,"pinker":51.8,"sen":48.1,"rockstrom":55.3,"taleb":44.2}},{"year":1988,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.28,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":39.6,"welfare":58.9,"knowledge":43.5,"freedom":34.9,"sustainability":58.1,"cooperation":56.6},"fragility":41.6,"civscore":{"balanced":52.1,"pinker":52.8,"sen":49,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":45}},{"year":1989,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.28,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.8,"welfare":59.2,"knowledge":43.9,"freedom":35.4,"sustainability":58,"cooperation":57.1},"fragility":39.9,"civscore":{"balanced":53.1,"pinker":54.2,"sen":49.9,"rockstrom":56.6,"taleb":46}},{"year":1990,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.2,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":37.8,"welfare":59.7,"knowledge":36.9,"freedom":36.5,"sustainability":57,"cooperation":57.5},"fragility":41.1,"civscore":{"balanced":51.6,"pinker":52.2,"sen":48.7,"rockstrom":55.5,"taleb":46}},{"year":1991,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.2,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":37.6,"welfare":60,"knowledge":37.3,"freedom":37.4,"sustainability":56.7,"cooperation":57.7},"fragility":41.1,"civscore":{"balanced":51.9,"pinker":52.5,"sen":49.2,"rockstrom":55.6,"taleb":46.4}},{"year":1992,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.2,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.7,"welfare":60.5,"knowledge":37.8,"freedom":38.3,"sustainability":57.1,"cooperation":59.9},"fragility":39.6,"civscore":{"balanced":53,"pinker":53.6,"sen":50.1,"rockstrom":56.6,"taleb":47.3}},{"year":1993,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.2,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.4,"welfare":61,"knowledge":38.2,"freedom":39,"sustainability":56.6,"cooperation":60},"fragility":38.9,"civscore":{"balanced":53.6,"pinker":54.4,"sen":50.8,"rockstrom":56.8,"taleb":47.8}},{"year":1994,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.2,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.5,"welfare":61.6,"knowledge":38.5,"freedom":39.6,"sustainability":56.1,"cooperation":61},"fragility":38.8,"civscore":{"balanced":53.9,"pinker":54.7,"sen":51.2,"rockstrom":56.9,"taleb":48.1}},{"year":1995,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.18,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":31.6,"welfare":62.3,"knowledge":38.9,"freedom":40.3,"sustainability":55.2,"cooperation":62.4},"fragility":38,"civscore":{"balanced":54.6,"pinker":55.6,"sen":52,"rockstrom":57.1,"taleb":48.6}},{"year":1996,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.12,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":30.1,"welfare":62.9,"knowledge":39.5,"freedom":40.9,"sustainability":55.3,"cooperation":62.9},"fragility":37.3,"civscore":{"balanced":55.2,"pinker":56.4,"sen":52.7,"rockstrom":57.6,"taleb":49.2}},{"year":1997,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.09,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":31.4,"welfare":63.5,"knowledge":40.3,"freedom":41.6,"sustainability":54.5,"cooperation":64.4},"fragility":37.5,"civscore":{"balanced":55.5,"pinker":56.6,"sen":53.1,"rockstrom":57.6,"taleb":49.6}},{"year":1998,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.09,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":31.4,"welfare":63.9,"knowledge":40.9,"freedom":42.3,"sustainability":53.6,"cooperation":65.3},"fragility":37.5,"civscore":{"balanced":55.8,"pinker":57,"sen":53.6,"rockstrom":57.5,"taleb":49.9}},{"year":1999,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.09,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.9,"welfare":64.6,"knowledge":41.8,"freedom":43.2,"sustainability":54.1,"cooperation":66},"fragility":38.3,"civscore":{"balanced":55.8,"pinker":56.8,"sen":53.9,"rockstrom":57.6,"taleb":50.1}},{"year":2000,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.06,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.5,"welfare":65.4,"knowledge":42.4,"freedom":44,"sustainability":53.7,"cooperation":69.1},"fragility":37.2,"civscore":{"balanced":56.7,"pinker":57.7,"sen":54.8,"rockstrom":58.2,"taleb":50.8}},{"year":2001,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.06,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":27.9,"welfare":66,"knowledge":43.3,"freedom":44.5,"sustainability":52.7,"cooperation":68.7},"fragility":35.5,"civscore":{"balanced":57.9,"pinker":59.5,"sen":55.9,"rockstrom":58.7,"taleb":52.1}},{"year":2002,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.03,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":26.2,"welfare":66.7,"knowledge":44,"freedom":45.1,"sustainability":52.1,"cooperation":68.9},"fragility":35.1,"civscore":{"balanced":58.4,"pinker":60.3,"sen":56.6,"rockstrom":58.8,"taleb":52.7}},{"year":2003,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.03,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":26.6,"welfare":67.4,"knowledge":44.8,"freedom":45.7,"sustainability":51.6,"cooperation":70.1},"fragility":35,"civscore":{"balanced":58.8,"pinker":60.7,"sen":57.1,"rockstrom":59,"taleb":53.1}},{"year":2004,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.03,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.5,"welfare":68.1,"knowledge":45.4,"freedom":46.2,"sustainability":51.3,"cooperation":72.6},"fragility":33.9,"civscore":{"balanced":59.7,"pinker":61.6,"sen":57.9,"rockstrom":59.6,"taleb":53.8}},{"year":2005,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0.03,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.4,"welfare":68.9,"knowledge":46,"freedom":46.6,"sustainability":50.4,"cooperation":74},"fragility":33.7,"civscore":{"balanced":60.1,"pinker":62.1,"sen":58.5,"rockstrom":59.7,"taleb":54.2}},{"year":2006,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.4,"welfare":69.5,"knowledge":46.8,"freedom":46.8,"sustainability":50,"cooperation":75.6},"fragility":33.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.5,"pinker":62.7,"sen":59,"rockstrom":59.9,"taleb":54.8}},{"year":2007,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25.6,"welfare":70.2,"knowledge":47.6,"freedom":46.9,"sustainability":49.5,"cooperation":76.1},"fragility":33.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":63,"sen":59.3,"rockstrom":59.9,"taleb":54.8}},{"year":2008,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":28,"welfare":70.7,"knowledge":48.6,"freedom":47.1,"sustainability":49.4,"cooperation":77.3},"fragility":33.8,"civscore":{"balanced":60.9,"pinker":63,"sen":59.5,"rockstrom":59.9,"taleb":54.7}},{"year":2009,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":28.7,"welfare":71.2,"knowledge":49.6,"freedom":47.1,"sustainability":48.5,"cooperation":72.3},"fragility":36,"civscore":{"balanced":60,"pinker":62.6,"sen":59.1,"rockstrom":58.6,"taleb":54.2}},{"year":2010,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":25,"welfare":71.9,"knowledge":50.5,"freedom":47.2,"sustainability":47.7,"cooperation":75.2},"fragility":34,"civscore":{"balanced":61.3,"pinker":64.1,"sen":60.2,"rockstrom":59.4,"taleb":54.9}},{"year":2011,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":26.8,"welfare":72.4,"knowledge":51.3,"freedom":47.5,"sustainability":47.6,"cooperation":77.2},"fragility":34,"civscore":{"balanced":61.5,"pinker":64.3,"sen":60.6,"rockstrom":59.7,"taleb":55}},{"year":2012,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":31.6,"welfare":73,"knowledge":52.2,"freedom":47.6,"sustainability":47,"cooperation":77.2},"fragility":35.8,"civscore":{"balanced":60.9,"pinker":63.6,"sen":60.3,"rockstrom":59,"taleb":54.1}},{"year":2013,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.8,"welfare":73.6,"knowledge":52.7,"freedom":47.6,"sustainability":46.3,"cooperation":76.8},"fragility":36.9,"civscore":{"balanced":60.5,"pinker":63.3,"sen":60.2,"rockstrom":58.4,"taleb":53.4}},{"year":2014,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36,"welfare":74,"knowledge":54,"freedom":47.4,"sustainability":45.7,"cooperation":76.4},"fragility":38,"civscore":{"balanced":60.3,"pinker":63.1,"sen":60.1,"rockstrom":57.9,"taleb":52.7}},{"year":2015,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.8,"welfare":74.4,"knowledge":54.8,"freedom":47.2,"sustainability":44.7,"cooperation":75},"fragility":39,"civscore":{"balanced":59.9,"pinker":63,"sen":59.9,"rockstrom":57.2,"taleb":51.9}},{"year":2016,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":36.1,"welfare":74.9,"knowledge":55.9,"freedom":47,"sustainability":43.8,"cooperation":73.9},"fragility":39.5,"civscore":{"balanced":59.9,"pinker":63.3,"sen":60.1,"rockstrom":56.8,"taleb":51.3}},{"year":2017,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":34.9,"welfare":75.2,"knowledge":56.5,"freedom":46.7,"sustainability":43.6,"cooperation":74.9},"fragility":38.8,"civscore":{"balanced":60.3,"pinker":63.8,"sen":60.4,"rockstrom":57.1,"taleb":51.5}},{"year":2018,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.1,"welfare":75.6,"knowledge":57.5,"freedom":46.6,"sustainability":43.3,"cooperation":75.9},"fragility":38,"civscore":{"balanced":61,"pinker":64.7,"sen":61,"rockstrom":57.5,"taleb":51.7}},{"year":2019,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":33.7,"welfare":75.9,"knowledge":58.7,"freedom":46.3,"sustainability":42.4,"cooperation":75.2},"fragility":38.7,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":64.7,"sen":61,"rockstrom":57,"taleb":51}},{"year":2020,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":35.4,"welfare":75.7,"knowledge":60.7,"freedom":46.1,"sustainability":41.7,"cooperation":72.8},"fragility":40.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.3,"pinker":64.4,"sen":60.7,"rockstrom":56.1,"taleb":50.1}},{"year":2021,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.1,"welfare":75.3,"knowledge":61.9,"freedom":46.1,"sustainability":41.8,"cooperation":75.8},"fragility":40.8,"civscore":{"balanced":60.1,"pinker":63.9,"sen":60.6,"rockstrom":56.2,"taleb":49.8}},{"year":2022,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":42.2,"welfare":76.4,"knowledge":62.9,"freedom":46,"sustainability":41.3,"cooperation":79.4},"fragility":40.5,"civscore":{"balanced":60.6,"pinker":64.3,"sen":61.2,"rockstrom":56.5,"taleb":49.6}},{"year":2023,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":39.1,"welfare":76.8,"knowledge":63.7,"freedom":46,"sustainability":40,"cooperation":77.1},"fragility":40.7,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":64.9,"sen":61.4,"rockstrom":56,"taleb":49}},{"year":2024,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0.06,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":39.7,"welfare":77.2,"knowledge":64.6,"freedom":46.1,"sustainability":39.4,"cooperation":76.4},"fragility":41.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.7,"pinker":65,"sen":61.5,"rockstrom":55.7,"taleb":48.6}},{"year":2025,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0.1,"provisional":false,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.6,"welfare":77.4,"knowledge":65.7,"freedom":45.6,"sustainability":39.5,"cooperation":77.2},"fragility":41.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":65.1,"sen":61.6,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":48.6}},{"year":2026,"estimate":false,"estimateShare":0,"carriedShare":0.98,"provisional":true,"dimensions":{"conflict":40.6,"welfare":77.4,"knowledge":65.7,"freedom":45.6,"sustainability":39.5,"cooperation":77.2},"fragility":41.3,"civscore":{"balanced":60.8,"pinker":65.1,"sen":61.6,"rockstrom":55.8,"taleb":48.6}}]}